The UK economy’s impact on higher education recruitment

Many articles discuss how higher education institutions have long contributed to the economy. However, there’s been little focus on the effects of the UK’s turbulent economy over the last five years on recruiting key academic and non-academic professionals who support this contribution.

The UK has faced significant economic challenges recently, including Brexit, the COVID-19 pandemic, and fluctuating market conditions. These events have created uncertainty and financial strain across various sectors, including higher education. Universities and colleges have had to navigate budget cuts, changing funding models, and shifts in student enrollment patterns, all of which have affected their ability to attract and retain staff.

This guide examines how the UK’s turbulent economy has impacted higher education recruitment over the past year and provides future predictions. It highlights five key areas affected by economic conditions, offering insights into current challenges and trends to navigate recruitment strategies effectively.

Impact of the turbulent UK economy

The economy and higher education are closely linked; when one struggles, the other often does too. Over the past year, the UK's shaky economy has significantly impacted higher education, particularly in recruiting academic and non-academic staff.

With the unstable economy, finding and retaining staff has become much tougher. More students are enrolling in universities than ever before, but the economic downturn means there’s less money available to hire the necessary staff to support them.

Economic pressures have affected salaries and job security, making attracting and retaining talent harder. This situation is worsened by the lingering effects of COVID-19, which already strained university budgets and forced a shift to online learning.

Let’s examine the key areas of higher education recruitment most affected by economic uncertainty last year.

1. Budget constraints

The UK higher education sector is facing serious financial challenges right now. Cuts in government funding and capped tuition fees are putting a lot of pressure on university budgets, especially when it comes to hiring staff.

According to the Office for Students' 2024 report, these economic issues are hard-hitting to the financial health of higher education providers in England. Over the past decade, government funding for teaching has dropped by 78%, and tuition fees have been capped at £9,250. This means universities rely more on student fees and loans to keep things running, including hiring staff.

How budget constraints continue to affect higher education recruitment:

• Limited funds: Funding for performing arts courses is frozen at £16.7 million for 2024-25, nearly half of what was before 2020. This makes it challenging for universities to find and keep staff in these important areas, potentially leading to talent shortages and fewer course offerings.
• Competitive disadvantage: With tighter budgets, universities struggle to compete for top talent. They might not be able to offer the best salaries or benefits, making it hard to attract and keep good staff.
• Tough choices: Budget pressures force universities to decide where to spend their money. Core academic areas continue to be prioritised over specialised fields like performing arts, which affects hiring and the overall student experience.
• Sector-wide impact: The overall financial squeeze means there’s a lot of competition for the limited funds available for staff recruitment. Universities need to develop creative solutions and work together to ensure they can still hire the staff they need.

Despite these challenges, there are reasons to be optimistic. Many universities are innovating and adapting in impressive ways. They are exploring new partnerships with industries, leveraging technology to enhance learning, and finding new ways to engage students and staff. 

However, universities' resilience can only stretch so far. These institutions' long-term sustainability remains uncertain without substantial funding and policy changes. Actual change is needed to ensure that the higher education sector can continue to thrive and provide high-quality education in the future.

2. Job market uncertainty

The UK's higher education sector, still recovering from COVID-19, faces renewed uncertainty amidst significant budget cuts and economic constraints, impacting both academic and non-academic staff.

Universities are continuously trying to implement measures to manage tighter finances, including cost savings and restructuring courses. These actions heighten uncertainty among staff, exacerbating job market challenges.

Despite a history of resilience, the sector now grapples with reduced government funding and capped tuition fees, profoundly affecting stability. While rebuilding post-pandemic, universities confront heightened financial pressures and increased job market volatility.

Impact on academic and non-academic staff:

• Job insecurity: Reduced funding and uncertain income streams have heightened job insecurity across the sector. Academic staff may struggle to secure funding for research and teaching, while non-academic staff face potential layoffs or reduced benefits.
• Financial constraints: Like many other public sectors post-COVID-19, higher education faces ongoing economic pressures, which affect current staffing levels and future recruitment.
• Diversity and inclusion challenges: Job cuts and hiring freezes disproportionately affect staff from diverse backgrounds, challenging universities' efforts to maintain inclusive environments.
• Career uncertainty: Higher education employees face uncertainty about their future roles and careers as they contend with competition from industries offering more stable employment conditions.

Universities and higher education institutions are actively seeking solutions to mitigate financial constraints. Strategic initiatives include exploring alternative revenue sources, forming partnerships with industry and government, and advocating for supportive policies. 

3. Salary and benefits

Maintaining competitive salary packages and benefits in the UK higher education sector has become increasingly challenging amidst budget cuts and financial pressures. As part of the public service, the industry faces significant constraints in offering competitive compensation packages.

The cost of living crisis complicates matters, with professionals often seeking higher salaries, prompting some to consider roles in the private sector. This crisis has affected nearly everyone in the UK, particularly those in working-class positions, heightening concerns about the sector's ability to attract and retain top talent.

Key issues:

• Financial pressures and competitive salaries: Universities reliant on student loans and facing budget cuts may struggle to offer competitive salaries and benefits packages. This challenge diminishes their ability to attract and retain high-calibre academic and administrative professionals.
• Private sector competition: The private sector often offers higher salaries, drawing candidates away from higher education roles. This competition requires higher education institutions to offer more attractive compensation packages to secure qualified staff.
• Cost of living crisis: The ongoing cost of living crisis in the UK puts pressure on existing salaries. University staff, like everyone else, are facing rising housing, food, and transportation costs. This can lead to dissatisfaction and a higher turnover rate as staff seek better compensation elsewhere.

These challenges underline universities' difficulty maintaining competitive salary and benefits packages amid financial constraints and private-sector competition. The sector's ability to attract and retain talent is crucial for sustaining educational excellence and operational efficiency.

4. Brexit’s long-term impact

Since the Brexit referendum 2016, UK universities have been grappling with ongoing uncertainties. One of the major concerns is how Brexit continues to affect research funding, including the £82 billion Horizon Europe programme, essential for maintaining British scientific excellence and attracting top talent. Additionally, funding cuts to grant-reliant institutions have exacerbated financial pressures across disciplines, impacting recruitment and program quality. 

These financial uncertainties also influence student enrollments, affect university revenues, and potentially lead to job cuts. This discussion explores how Brexit's current impact shapes the future of higher education in the UK.

Brexit’s Ongoing Impact on Higher Education:

• Research funding challenges: Brexit has created ongoing uncertainties around research funding, particularly from programmes contributing to research funding. As financial pressures continue to rise and funding diminishes, universities' ability to attract and retain research talent remains risky.
• Financial strain: Continued funding cuts to universities heavily reliant on grants are straining budgets and affecting recruitment efforts. This economic pressure jeopardises the quality of education and services universities can offer.
• Fluctuating student numbers: Uncertainty surrounding Brexit has led to fluctuations in international student enrollments, impacting university revenues and potentially leading to job insecurity among staff.

These ongoing challenges highlight the importance of universities adapting strategically to maintain competitiveness and uphold academic standards amidst Brexit's evolving impact on higher education in the UK.

5. Immigration policies

The UK's higher education sector faces immediate challenges due to its growing dependence on international student fees, which are projected to constitute between 33% and 66% of all course fee income by 2026/27.

However, recent changes in immigration policies, particularly those affecting family visas, compound these challenges and directly influence student enrollments and university finances. The continued reliance on international student fees in higher education to fund recruitment and other essential operations makes universities vulnerable to fluctuations in international enrollment.

These changes have resulted in:

• Decline in student numbers: Tightened restrictions on family visas have diminished the UK's attractiveness as a study destination for international students, leading to a notable reduction in applications and enrollments.
• Financial pressures: Universities relying heavily on international student fees are experiencing financial strain as enrollments decline. The current academic year has seen a significant 40% drop in international student numbers, impacting revenue streams.
• Impact on staffing: Reduced international student enrollments threaten university budgets, potentially necessitating budget cuts and affecting job security across academic and non-academic staff roles. 

Navigating these challenges is critical for universities to maintain competitiveness and uphold academic standards amidst evolving immigration policies. Finding a balance between financial sustainability and attracting international talent will be crucial for the long-term viability of UK higher education institutions.

Looking to the future of higher education staffing

The future of UK higher education funding remains uncertain but hopeful, with ongoing discussions about potential changes like raising tuition fees or implementing a graduate tax. No definitive decisions have been made yet.

Predictions suggest an improved outlook from 2026-27 based on income from course fees and education contracts. Still, this year, there have been several reports of dropping international student numbers due to factors like currency devaluation in Nigeria, political tensions with China, and UK government restrictions on master's students bringing family members.

In the short term, 40% of England’s universities expected to run budget deficits and a slow process of changing the funding model. Additionally, the UK's turbulent economy, affected by Brexit, COVID-19, and fluctuating market conditions, has strained recruitment efforts for both academic and non-academic staff.

Universities are adapting by focusing on employability and increasing collaboration with industries, leading to more efficient resource use and new funding streams. While the new Labour government has recognised the situation in higher education, their current manifesto is focused on schools.

Despite these challenges, the sector's commitment to addressing funding issues and enhancing collaboration offers hope for a stable and prosperous future for UK higher education.

Higher education recruitment amid economic change: Final thoughts

Over the past year, the UK's economy has heavily impacted higher education recruitment. The combination of Brexit uncertainties, the lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, and fluctuations in funding has created significant challenges for universities. Budget cuts, changes in student enrollment patterns, and job market uncertainties have necessitated strategic responses from institutions.

Navigating these economic realities will require ongoing adaptation, proactive planning, and a focus on maintaining institutional resilience and competitiveness in recruiting academic and non-academic staff.

Transforming higher education careers

At TPP, we're dedicated to matching talented individuals with rewarding careers in higher education. Our specialised teams understand industry trends and offer tailored solutions for every job seeker. With a deep understanding of the economy's impact on higher education recruitment, we have a proven track record of placing quality candidates in leading organisations.

Contact us today to discover how we can assist you in finding talent in a challenging market.